I found a new iPhone 5. Will I get in trouble?

On Friday morning I found this iphone in panera bread without a password lock. The previous owner, a young 19 year old spoiled girl has failed to pick it up. The moment I found it, she called 50 times asking for me to return it. I initially agreed and flirted with her a little by saying, I hope my reward is dinner at your place. She immediately raised her voice and said "I just want my f$%King phone not a date plus you sound too old". I said ok well you have 24 hours to claim it. She didn't call me until Saturday night about 33 hours later. When I told her that she missed the 24 hour period, she cursed me out and cried on the phone. Her mother called back and threatened me, I hung up again and took the SIM card out. I've since place my sim card in the phone and it works fine. What could happen?

You won't get in too much trouble I wouldn't think. But if the girl contacts the police or anything then you could be charged for stealing. It may be embarrassing, but the best thing for everyone would just be to return the phone, or even send it to her by mail if you don't want to be caught up in an awkward, messy situation.

Theft by finding, take it to a police station

You sound super classy

watch your back sweetie

youll cross the wrong person soon enough

You are guilty of theft by conversion.