Can I get the iPhone 4 for $2?

Hi everyone so I have the iPhone 4S in white. About 1 year ago (July 2012) I dropped it and the screen shattered. I went to the apple store and they said I would have to buy a whole new phone for $200.So I did not want to do that. I've dealt with a shattered screen for a year somehow. So now, my home button is broken. I have to use the on screen accessibility.So, my friend told me I should just replace it with the iPhone 4. Do you think I would have to pay full price for it? Or I could get it replaced for $1.99? I would rather have a good working iPhone 4 than a shattered and broken iPhone 4S. My upgrade is in December 2013 and I got my iPhone 4S in December 2011.

If you are still on contract, you will have to pay full price for the Iphone 4 ($400-500). $1.99 is merely the subsidized pricing with a new contract.