Can I trade my white iPhone 5 for a black one?

Yesterday I got a free replacement due to a broken power button. Do you think I can trade this iPhone 5 in for a new black iPhone 5?

Additional info: My carrier is Verizon. I got my iPhone for full price, therefore I have unlimited date. I got my new iPhone from th apple store though.

Now that you have it, its a used phone so I'm guesing no.

No, if you did an exchange/ etc, it would be the same phone.

No color trade in.