How to transfer clash of clans from old acct to new one?

So i got an iphone 5s and i had an iphone 4 before. I would like to transfer from 4 to 5s, but it only asks my iphone 4 if i would like to load my lvl 2 village and doesn't ask if i want to load my lvl 58 village on my iphone 5s.

If you upgraded to the atrocity that is iOS 8 it won't work anyway so I wouldn't bother. Seriously, if you're doing this through iTunes and the new phone doesn't recognize your game it means the app isn't compatible with the new operating system.