Otter box Defender vs Commuter?

I have an iPhone four in a defender case and I love it but the silicone is ripping and streatched after all this time the commuter has a hard outside but does it protect as well?

If you want it to fit in your pocket comfortably, go with the commuter. Also if you drop it with the commuter case your iphone will be completely safe in the commuter unless you just blatantly miss treat it. So in the end its up to you!

  • Will Otter replace my Otter Box? Ok so on my iPhone 4 otterbox the rubber is breaking off, the hard part is breaking to pieces and the plastic screen is coming off. My mom sent pics to Otter online and I heard the will replace it. Will they?
  • Will an iPhone 5 commuter series otter box fit an iPhone 5s? I'm upgrading to an iPhone 5s in March. I just ordered a commuter series otter box, forgetting that the cameras and home buttons are slightly different on the 5 and 5s. Do you think it will fit? I want to cancel my order if it won't!
  • Which protects the iphone 4 better: an otter box or case mate? I'm getting an iphone4. I have in the past had an iphone3 and used an otterbox defender. This time I'm wanting to get something a little more stylish. I NEED the protection tho! So I'm wondering if the case mate protects as well as an otterbox?
  • Should i get Otterbox Defender or Commuter? I'm getting an iPhone 4S tomorrow. I'm not a very clumsy person but i do drop my iPod touch occasionally. I want a case that allows my phone to still fit in my pants pocket. It needs to be a sturdy phone and i will put my phone in my backpack for school. Thanks! Needs to be a sturdy CASE not phone