Otterbox or Lifeproof for iPhone 5c?

I've already dropped and cracked my screen twice, so I figure it's time to buy a case. I've heard pros and cons for both, which do you prefer?

Lifeproof Fre: it's waterproof. Most Otterbox cases aren't. The Fre provides better durability than the Nuud.

Also my 5s looks brand new after months of construction work and many times being in soaked pants.