Will otter box make me return my old Otterbox to them?

I bought my Otterbox for my iPhone 4S just 3 months ago and the silicone already started to tear from the vibrate part. So I contacted them through email and they said they will be sending me a new one. My question, will I return my old one or can I go ahed and give it to my little brother for his 4?

I highly doubt theyll make you return it

  • Will Otter replace my Otter Box? Ok so on my iPhone 4 otterbox the rubber is breaking off, the hard part is breaking to pieces and the plastic screen is coming off. My mom sent pics to Otter online and I heard the will replace it. Will they?
  • Which protects the iphone 4 better: an otter box or case mate? I'm getting an iphone4. I have in the past had an iphone3 and used an otterbox defender. This time I'm wanting to get something a little more stylish. I NEED the protection tho! So I'm wondering if the case mate protects as well as an otterbox?
  • Which iphone 5 otter box case is better? The defender or the commuter. I'm torn between the two because I read that if dust get in the defender case the iphone 5 screen to get scratch. But the commuter doesn't have a built in screen Protector that protect the screen or logo.
  • What's the name of the iphone 4 otter box cases that are skinny? Its like two color and i see everyone with one! I have an all white iphone 4 with no case! The case is an otter box but made different, its not fat like the original ones and it has a earphone plugg in the top of it! If this helps, i see people with a purple and grey one and it has otter box on the back i think!