Would Otterbox replace my case?

Ok my iphone 4 was stolen out of my locker and my case was on it. I received the case with a holder about 3 months ago. Will otterbox replace my case? If so how can i explain it to them so i can get another 1?
P.S i got iphone back but theif did something with case i have no idea what he did. I really need another case before something happens to my phone

  • Would you get the Otterbox Defender or the Speck Candy Shell? I'm getting the 4s soon and I can't decide which of these two cases to get. Perks of the Otterbox is that it has a built in screen protector, it will protect your iPhone no matter what. But I don't like how it's so bulky. Perks of the Candy Shell is that its way slimmer than the Otterbox, and it's shock absorbent. But I'm not sure if it'll protect the phone just as good as an Otterbox.
  • Would My iPhone Screen Crack If I Take Off The Otterbox Plastic Screen? I Have A iPhone 5 With An Otterbox Defender Case. It Has A Plastic On The Screen iWas Wondering If iTook Of The Plastic Will My Screen Crack If It Falls?
  • Would a normal iPhone 5 otterbox fit on an iPhone 5c? I was thinking about getting the iPhone 5c, I really like it. But I really need an otterbox on it. Will a normal iPhone 5 otterbox fit onto an iPhone 5c? I know the iPhone 5c corners are bit different, but would it work afterall?
  • Will OtterBox replace my iPhone? A week or two ago, I dropped my iPhone and the screen cracked. The phone had an OtterBox case on it when I dropped it. Will OtterBox have to replace my phone if I turn it in?