Clean iPhone 4 or Scratched iPhone 4S?

So, I can either choose a clean iPhone 4 (no wear marks, no scratches, but home button needs to be pressed heavily or won't work only some of the time). Or, I can choose an iPhone 4S that has a lot of small scratches all over the screen and surroundings, and two big scratches on the back. Both are 16 GB. I know the iPhone 4S is faster, but I really get annoyed by the small scratches. The iPhone 4 looks almost new, but the 4S looks like it had been dropped sometimes. Oh, and one more thing, If i put a screen protector over the 4S, will I still be able to see the scratches even with the screen protector on? I don't know. I'll leave it up to you guys.

Id go with the 4S. Eventually the iPhone 4 will quit working with the home button *** up. And its possible for the screan protector to help not see.

  • Will screen protector show bubbles on my scratched iphone? I just got my iphone 5s about 4 weeks ago and my friend has a screen protector that I'm going to buy tomorrow. I looked at my screen, and there's a tiny scratch on it that you can only see when you look at it in direct light. When I put the screen protector on it, will there be a air bubble where the little scratch is?
  • What will happen if the black part behind my iPhone screen is scratched when the iPhone is apart? So I was going to replace my iPhone screen but we realized that we ordered the wrong thing so while my phone was apart I was putting the 6 acres back together that's on the left and right side of the screen and the black part got scratched and when I turn the phone on there's a bunch of colorfully lines and I can't use the phone. Is that scratch the reason the lines are on it like that?
  • My iPhone screen protector is scratched up? I just want to know if my phone is harmed in any way. Or is it literally just the screen protector that got scratched up? Also, if you know how to get rid of these scratches on a protective screen, please do not hesitate to tell me! Also, if you have any other tips for me, please let me know!
  • My iphone screen gets scratched even with screen protector? I have an iphone 4 in white and i bought it with a screen protector. I keep it very safe, never dropped, i, never put it in a pocket full of stuff.yet, i have several hairline scratches.within a week's use. I don't think i pressed that hard on the screen either. I treated my iphone 3g with the same treatment and even dropped it twice. I didn't even have a screen protector on it! So why does my iphone 4 keep getting scratched!