Do iPhone 4, 4S or 5 screens break as easily as 3GS screens?

I dropped my 3GS a while back and the screen shattered, it cracked again today after I accidently hit it, so would an upgrade be less likely to crack?

The newer iPhones actually break MORE than the iPhone 3Gs would. This is because newer iPhones are made of more glass (the front and back are both glass). Maybe try a different type of phone, or get a tough case.

The new ones are made out of gorilla glass

The iPhone 4 and 4S will break just as easily (and scratches more easily) but the iPhone 5 is a bit more durable, since it's made of Gorilla Glass.

http://readwrite.com/2012/09/25/assessing-the-durability-of-the-iphone-5

This site has a couple of videos showing the durability of the iPhone 5.

I dropped my 3gs like 5 times and it never broke. Dropped my 4s once and it shattered the screen. Granted, my 4s fell flat on its face when i dropped it and for whatever reason my 3gs always landed sideways etc only scratching the non-glass areas. That made the difference.

I had the same problem, broke my screen after dropping my 4s. I bought a Griffin I phone 4s protective case. It looks bulky with a picture but its not. It's brilliant. Screen is easily accessible. It's perfect. Phone flew out my pocket only yesterday when I was cycling. Doing 35-40 mph down a long steep hill. Not a scratch on my phone or screen. Still looks brand new. The case is fine as well. It's made out of some sort of rubber that absorbs the impact when it's dropped. When it flew out my pocket it bounced down the road. Absolutely nothing wrong with it. I bought the case from an o2 shop. I can't remember what I paid for it but yesterday it saved me hundreds of pound. When I say case, the screens not covered by something, so you don't have to lift a flap up every time you want to use your phone. It's covered by a thin plastic. I've no issue regarding the touch screen element of it. Works like its uncovered. Seriously, I can't recommend it enough. Had the case for over a year. Still in good condition.

  • Why don't iPhones work well? IPhones break easily and are laggy? Hi. I have an iPhone 5 and I have many problems with it. Whenever I type on my iPhone 5, the texts that I type come out like 5 seconds after I type them. It's very unresponsive and lagging. My previous iPhone broke in just 2 years. Is Nokia a better brand than Apple?
  • Why do people say iPhones break easily? I dropped it on solid concrete many times, and it even landed screen first at one occasion. It doesn't have a protective case or anything and still no scratch on any side
  • Why do people break their iPhones so easily? I have the 3gs, and I've had it for almost a year, and I know people with iPhones that they crack in no time. I have a friend that got the 5 for her birthday like 3 weeks ago, and the screen in already cracked… How does that happen? I'm not even that careful with my phone and I drop it all the time and it has a couple scratches on the screen protector but other than that, I don't really protect it. How do people break their phones so easily?
  • What is the best iPhone 5 charger to buy that will not break easily? My iPhone chargers have broken every time I got them. I have spent a lot of money buying new ones and i don't like it. Is there any charger that will not break easily?