Otterbox Commuter or Symmetry for iPhone 6s plus?

So I recently dropped my iPhone 6 and it was completely destroyed. The screen would not work. Today I bought the iPhone 6s Plus and I was wondering which case would be more protective. I understand the defender would be the best option but I just don't like how big it is. I also read somewhere that the symmetry case is actually more protective then the commuter. I would like to know what you guys think. Otterbox Commuter or Otterbox Symmetry!

Lmao