Silicone vs Hard case. Which one is more protective?

I have a 3D Mickey Mouse (silicone) case on my iPhone 5 right now.

I prefer a silicone case since it will absorb some shock and is more comfortable to hold.

Your is a good choice. I recently got a belt clip with a "soft impact case" that securely holds the phone in the clip, which swivels. I like it so far. Sorry I don't know the name of it but I got a deal at $20.