Which iPhone 4 case should I get? - 1

So I need to get a new iPhone case because my Mophie Juice Case just broke. I have about 300$ to spend on a case, although obviously I do not want to spend it all. These are the cases I'm considering:
1.LifeProof Limited Edition RealTree Case-89.99
http://m.lifeproof.com/shop/us_en/iphone-4s-4/lifeproof-realtree-for-iphone-4-4s/

2.Another Mophie Juice Case-I'm actually kind of hesitant to buy another one because although I like the extra battery life, the case itself is kind of bulky and the plastic/metal breaks off easily.

3.Otterbox Defender Case
http://www.otterbox.com/iPhone-4/4S-Defender-Series-Build-Your-Own-Case/apl2-iphone-4s-set,default,pd.html

Other suggestions would also be appreciated.

Pretty sure you can get cases very very similar to otterbox on amazon for a quarter of the price.

Whichever you like

For your iPhone, I suggest you try that silico one. They have a high quality for protecting your iPhone
http://www.3ds-cart.com/27-iphone4s55s5c-cases
Which iPhone 4 case should I get - 2