Otterbox reflex or commuter?

I'm getting an iPhone 4S and i want the most protective case for a crack in my screen? Which is better?

The reflex case is a hard case that is easy to remove. It is also designed to make it easier to dock your phone.

The Commuter case is much more protective, with a soft shock absorbing layer and a hard protective outer layer. It protects the phone from impacts, such as dropping it. It offers much more protection than the reflex case, but is a little more bulky, and you can't dock your phone with the case on.

http://www.otterbox.com/commuter-series/commuter-series, default, pg.html

http://www.otterbox.com/reflex-series/reflex-series, default, pg.html

  • What iPhone 5 case should I get? Otterbox Commuter or Speck Candy Shell? - 1 Can you tell me about PROTECTION SLEEKNESS WHICH ONE YOU WOULD GET COLORS THAT LOOK GOOD WITH THE WHITE ONE AND OTHER STUFF
  • Otterbox Defender, Impact, or Commuter? I'm in need of an Otterbox for my iPhone 3gs. I don't know which to order… The Defender, the Impact, or the Commuter. What is your advice for the best one? Ordering online is hard since I can't hold them in my hand. My friend had the Defender whichi s pretty bulky, but I didn't know if the other two would give as good of protection. Thoughts?
  • Otterbox commuter or defender? I have a black iPhone 4S and I been debating wether to get the white and gunmetal grey, defender or the black commuter. I have not rough with my phone, but I do not like have to have a broken iPhone. I heard some cons about both cases. And I was wondering what case I should get, listing the pros and cons.
  • Otterbox commuter for iPhone 4 fit the iPhone 4S? I have a white iPhone 4S. I found a PERFECT otterbox commuter case really cheap and rare to find. It says it doesn't fit the iPhone 4S. It's made for the iPhone 4. But I have an Otterbox defender case that's meant for the iPhone 4 and says it won't for the iPhone 4S but it does. Does anyone know if an otterbox commuter series case that's meant for an iPhone 4 fit an iPhone 4S!