What iPhone 4 case is better?

What case is better for a iPhone 4? Otter box defender or a life proof case? Life proof protects from dust, water, shock and bounce, otter box defends it from drops and scratches any opinions I need help to choise

What should my punishment be?

So my parents are letting me pick my punishment, but I need help, because I don't want it too be too bad, but also enough so they think they are punishing me.
So what I did to get myself into this mess…
I just graduated highschool so I'm 18, and my family was driving back from a graduation party. We got home at 11 and my crush texted me to hang out at 10. I haven't seen him in a long time and I just wanted to hang out until 12.So from 11-12, one hour, and I would drive myself so they could good to bed. They said no. And I beg and pleaded, offered to do a bunch or chores and not to go out later but it was still no. My parents are very strict usually and I was tired of it because I just graduated and I wanted to have fun! I know I shouldn't have, but I called my friend as she pick me up. I hung out with my crush, and then was back at 12. My parents figured out I was gone at like 11:55 and I was home 5 minutes after. I have never done anything "bad" really before and now my parents are making me choose my punishment. Probably whatever I say will be doubled. I really want to hang out with my crush again this Saturday, so I rather not be grounded. I was thinkin giving up my iphone for a week? But i could still go on the computer? Please suggest something that seems fair, but not outrageous.

Iphone Speaker Very Scratchy

Last Night I Ate Some Chocolate Icecream, I Dint really see anything get into my speaker. Later that niggt i played music and notice that it was not as loud as it normally is. I turned up everything. I looked at the speaker it had some chocolate in it, i tried cleaning it but it didn't work. Today i've noticed that its very scratchy and disorted. I'm Very worried, my iphone 4s is almost 5 months old. Should i take it in to the store, is it the chocolate on the mysic speaker causeing this?